Ten sourced credibility checks, drawn from eight independent hosts — journalism codes of ethics (SPJ, AP), the IFCN fact-checking principles, news-literacy and media-trust research — consolidated here into eight tests in four groups. No single source supports more than two of the ten checks.
Credentials or fame alone prove nothing, and bias alone does not make a claim false — what matters is whether the specific claim survives these checks.
| Check | What to do | Red flag | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Takes responsibility for accuracy and verifies sources and technology | Check whether the person verifies the provenance and authenticity of the methods, sources and technology behind their news before releasing it, and takes responsibility for accuracy. | — | spj.org |
| Clearly identifies sources and technology shaping the news | Check that the person gives the full name of a source and enough information to identify the source and explain why that person is credible | — | ap.org |
| Attributes disputable information and establishes source credibility | Check whether the journalist attributes disputable claims to identifiable sources and explains why those sources are credible. | — | bloomdocs.org |
| Acknowledges and corrects mistakes promptly and prominently | Check whether the person acknowledges mistakes, corrects them promptly and prominently, and explains corrections and clarifications clearly. | — | spj.org |
| Verification — confirming facts before reporting | Check that names, dates, and claims were confirmed before publishing | — | reputationpros.com |
| Journalist's opinion writing and potential bias | Check whether the journalist who wrote the article also writes opinion pieces | The journalist also writes opinion pieces, which could indicate a bias that must be evaluated | newslit.org |
| Cites sources and separates reporting from opinion | Check whether the creator cites sources, links articles, and offers more than just their opinions | Giving only opinions instead of cited, linked reporting | poynter.org |
| Corroboration by multiple independent primary sources | Prioritize direct interviews with at least three independent, primary sources for every major claim, and confirm every significant claim with at least two independent, credible sources. | — | thenarrativepost.com |
| Same high standards of evidence and judgement for equivalent claims regardless of who made the claim | Share links to 10 fact checks published over the past year demonstrating non-partisanship, explaining how they show the same high standards of evidence for equivalent claims, the same essential process for every fact check, and that evidence dictates conclusions | Applying different standards of evidence and judgement to equivalent claims depending on who made the claim | ifcncodeofprinciples.poynter.org |
| Same high standards of evidence regardless of who made the claim | Share links to 10 fact checks from the past year demonstrating non-partisanship, the same standards of evidence for equivalent claims, the same essential process for every fact check, and conclusions dictated by the evidence | — | ifcncodeofprinciples.poynter.org |
Method: 10 credibility checks extracted from 8 distinct source hosts (journalism ethics codes, fact-checking principles, media-trust research), one row per check; overlapping rows were consolidated into the 8 scorecard tests above, each linked to its strongest source. “Red flag” is the warning sign named by the source where given. Nothing was cut.