In four of eight coding-agent loops code chooses every step; in the other four the LLM picks the next action while executable gates own acceptance

Asked (summary):

Find real, public repositories implementing coding-agent systems whose inner iterative loop — write code, run tests, review, fix, re-test — does actual code changes, and determine what controls that loop before emergency exit. Compare code-driven control with orchestrator-driven control, with controller/graph/prompt evidence, emergency exits, and concrete run data. Exclude generic orchestration frameworks, non-coding agents, theory/toys, and dynamic-task-ordering systems.

Eight shortlisted systems, one row each, drawn from six independent source hosts — no host backs more than one of the eight rows. The list is curated, not an exhaustive universe, and small codebases were allowed. Three code-driven entries (ExecCritic, RepairAgent, StateSeal) rest on primary or technical write-ups; the rest are repository evidence. One taxonomy correction is applied: RepairAgent is relabelled by decision ownership as orchestrator-driven inside code-enforced rails, because its LLM chooses which permitted tool to invoke while a finite-state machine and a 40-cycle budget only constrain availability.

Control-ownership matrix

code owns this decision the LLM owns this decision shared — human checkpoint or stated but unenforced

Exit evidence, system by system

Normal completion is listed apart from emergency exits. Run data appears only as implementation evidence of the loop running, not as a productivity claim.

Full comparison table

SystemStyleController / promptMechanismWhat is builtExitsRun dataSource

Comparison of 8 coding-agent systems with inner write–test–review–fix loops; one row per system from a curated shortlist across 6 independent source hosts (max 1 row per URL). Columns record who selects the next action, fixed code, test/review mandates, retry bounds, completion authority and exits; RepairAgent's style label overridden by decision ownership. Long mechanism and run-data texts shortened in the matrix; full excerpts kept in cards and table. Compiled from repositories and write-ups current at collection time.

This report was generated automatically by Keenable SELECT at a user's request, from publicly available web sources linked herein. Keenable does not review, verify, or endorse its contents and makes no representation as to accuracy, completeness, or timeliness; AI-based extraction may contain errors. Nothing in this report is investment, legal, financial, or other professional advice. All trademarks and referenced content remain the property of their respective owners; no affiliation or endorsement is implied. To report an error, rights concern, or request removal: legal@keenable.ai.

Keenable SELECTAsk your own question
Made with Keenable SELECT